The glorious mess presented in those three LBBs remains a persistent, insistent center of pestilence and inspiration that continues to infect peoples' imaginations with all manner of notions for how to tinker with this rule, revise that section, rework how these things get handled, etc., etc. It is almost as much a game in and of itself to re-edit the rules and to revamp them to suit your own unique vision and ingenium. And that is a major reason why the OD&D booklets continue to exert such an influence upon peoples' psyches.
It is the very vagueness and incompleteness, the broken and irritating parts of those rules that inspire and drive otherwise sane and sensible individuals to spend hours upon hours ranting and raving and researching and writing about ways to model the effect of antique gunpowder weapons on various forms of armor, how much of a load can a typical peasant/footman carry on their back, how much actual coins from Byzantine times (or other time periods) weigh or what the limitations on spell-casters ought to be based upon whether they are using a runic approach, classical grimoiric-style conjurations, upper-class Hermetic magick or something more shamanic in character. Everything was wide open and available for personal interpretation. Back in the earliest days of the game literally anything could happen. Wellesian Martian war machines could pop up just as easily as Barsoomian White Apes or something completely new and just whipped-up by the DM only moments before. Imagination was king and spontaneous improvisation was the rule, aided and abetted with tons of random tables, a DIY ethic that gleefully
My favorite supplement of all time is The Fantasy Gamer's Compendium from Gamescience (1983). It combined the previous smaller booklets of Mystery, Monsters, Demons, Sorcery, Shamans and Treasures into one collected supplement. The cover art is still cheesier than all get out, the type is tiny, there are hardly any interior illustrations but you could use the thing with any edition of any fantastic/medieval RPG out there with a minimum of fiddling around with it.
And that brings me to the point of this particular enterprise. Like many another kid ensnared in Gygax and Arneson's literary snare at an early age (it was the Seventies), I became enamoured with the notion of developing my own rules for my own settings and running my own games and I've been doing so, off and on, more or less for most of my life, in-between brief periods of lucidity, social activity, and so forth. I've been Old School as far as D&D goes for quite some time, and after re-locating my set of the OD&D booklets, re-reading them and realizing that no matter which books I bought or what setting I wrote, I was still using a variation on the rules I first learned way back when. Tinkering with the rules, developing settings, cobbling together Sandbox campaigns, intertwining my fiction and home-brewed mythos into the game and distilling it back out again...those things are very much part and parcel of the Old School Renaissance and my goal with this blog is to map out my personal efforts in peeling back the accreted gunk and get down to the roots of the system, challenge the lingering assumptions and maybe sacrifice up a few sacred cows to the process of developing a stripped-down core system that might or might not go anyplace or ever get used...but the process will be fun and in the course of things I expect to develop a few spin-offs such as Settings, mini-settings, alternative magic systems, new spells, new monsters (we most definitely DO plan to create a stand-alone S&W/LL/OSRIC compatible Bestiary!), and more.
This blog will focus on the mechanics, the discussions surrounding things like the role of alignment and how to convert it into a numbered attribute and/or stuff like that. The companion blog will flesh out a setting, be more fiction-oriented, and deliver on the new spells, new monsters, new items, etc. It will also flesh-out the notes on how to incorporate attributes to chakras, ley-lines and planes, alternative demonologies (driven by alternative cosmologies), the spectrum of consciousness as it applies to spirits/elementals/constructs, and more. (Yes, 101 Homunculi, Hybrids and Horrors will be among the things offered) Anyone who has participated in our old Italbar/Talibarr, Bazra, Xembor games--either from the old groups or from our various events at the local Cons--can tell you that what we are bringing to the table is definitely not more of the same old crap, not by a long shot. The companion blog will be ready to go in another couple of days, as we're in the midst of some other projects that are demanding a lot of attention.
So, hang on, things are about to get crazy-fun and you haven't seen anything yet.